Preamble
Today, I am twenty-eight years old. Were I to travel backwards in time and tell myself that Spock would continue to be as influential a role model in the future as he was at age 12, my younger self would, rather than being surprised, have found such a statement … eminently logical. There are probably a lot of blogs, tweets and facebook posts commemorating Leonard Nimoy's eightieth birthday today, and in so far as this one also serves that purpose, I'm glad to join in. And yes, this too will include a brief story of my own meeting with Nimoy. So then, you might ask, how is what I'm doing any different. Well for once, I'm not worried about uniqueness. I will say this though; Spock has affected my own makeup, and in so far as this is a tribute to Nimoy, it's also a tribute to Spock. Spock's speech patterns and patterns of thought imprinted themselves on me as a young child, a fact which is humorous and, some might say, pathetic. I don't hold to the latter opinion. I freely admit that Spock was something of a role model, and in this day and age when M&M, Fitty-Cent, Usher and Kesha influence our youth, Spock is a better candidate for a preteen's role model than many other possibilities. So, part one of this details, with examples, the silly and profound ways that Spock has been imprinted on my psyche and modes of self-expression. I deal with the Vulcan salute, influences on my vocabulary choices and also influences on my pattern of thought. I'll close with a list of my favorite Spock quotes (note that I refuse to employ the adjective ‘Spockian’), some funny, some profound, some famous and well-known, some obscure, some included for reasons you may understand, some, simply because I wanted them there. But that's for a bit later. Finally, this is not a Nimoy biography, as worthy a cause as that is. This is about Spock, Nimoy's most well-known and probably best beloved character, and my relationship to Spock, for whatever that may be worth to you, the reader. Enjoy. Or rather, derive what can logically be derived from my statement, as Spock would have it.
"Live Long and Prosper," Me, and The Vulcan Salute
I remember learning this hand gesture. I'd always wanted to know how it was done, but, being blind, I’d never seen it done on screen and no one could quite show me the proper finger positioning. Finally, a teacher of mine in the fall semester of my sixth grade year told me she knew how the gesture was made and positioned my hand properly, checking to make sure I was holding my arm and hand precisely. I was, of course, thrilled to discover that the gesture came naturally to me on either hand, and that most people simply couldn't hack it. Now in case you were going to ask, no, I can't raise one eyebrow as Spock does, because the ability to raise eyebrows independently is genetically linked, and both of mine elevate every time!
Nimoy himself developed the Vulcan salute to support his assertion that the "live long and prosper" line should be accompanied with something ritualistic-looking. He was inspired by a childhood memory of peaking during an orthodox Jewish ceremonial prayer at his grandfather’s synagogue, where he actually opened his eyes during prayer and watched the kohan (plural kohanim) blessing the congregation. In Jewish custom, both of the Kohan's hands are held out horizontally over the congregants, and the fingers are splayed out to resemble the Hebrew letter 'Shin,' (short for Shaddai, which means Almighty God)as the blessing is recited. Nimoy's innovation was to make it a one-handed gesture using the right hand, and too, to make the gesture vertical rather than what it is in the ceremonies. The words, "live long and prosper," as well as the traditional reply, "peace and long life," are each meant to be spoken while making the gesture. As an added bonus, and to show you that my trek fandom and Vulcanaphilia run deep, I add two additional things. The words, "live long and prosper," and its response were penned by the script writer Theodor Sturgeon and the phrases appear for the first time in the first episode of the Original Series' second season, "Amuck Time." I, being a linguist, wondered what the words would have been in Vulcan, and I was minded to reexamine the first Star Trek Motion Picture, and we find, "Tich tor ang tesmur," which is, "live long and prosper." Unfortunately, Vulcan never had a Mark Okrand to create it and drive it. For those who don't know, Mark Okrand is the linguist who developed Klingon, and Klingon, as we all know thanks to the Klingon Language Institute (www.kli.org), is fully alive and is the subject of serious scholarly study. Alas, not so for Vulcan.
Now those of you who know me well will certainly have seen me offer the Vulcan salute on countless occasions. In fact, I can do it using both hands, which is rare as I understand. When I was a preteen it was a bit of a showoff sort of thing. Nowadays, while I'm not exactly unconscious of doing it, it's not meant to be pretentious. Most people who have known me for a long time simply smile and return the gesture, my stand-in for a farewell wave in most cases. How many times have you been pulling out of the driveway and seen me raise my right hand towards you, fingers splayed? The answer? More than once! I will likely never stop doing it, and I do not doubt that my children will pick up the gesture, so much a trademark has it become of mine.
My Words
Ask my godmother what my most frequently used word was in the eighth grade when we met as teacher and student. I’m not sure she’ll remember. That’s ok, I do. ‘Indeed,’ I do. ‘Indeed,’ and ‘fascinating’ are Spock’s signature words. Note: ‘intriguing,’ contrary to some things I’ve heard bandied about, is not one of Spock’s more frequently used words. To set the record straight, ‘intriguing’ is Data’s word.
The word ‘indeed’ seems to have its own flavor. It’s not a word that’s terribly common in vernacular English, and in more formal discourse its use is rather restricted. All that to say, when someone says ‘indeed,’ it’s use is marked, or put another way, you’ll notice someone using it. “Are you going to the store?” “Yeah. Need anything?” Now let’s reimagine that dialogue. “Are you going to the store?” “Indeed. need anything?” Or you might answer, “indeed not.” My use of indeed was over the top, and I’d like to think I use the word less frequently today. Still, the word flavors my speech and my writing. All because of Spock you ask? … Indeed.
No word, none, however, was as overused by me or brings Spock so forcibly to my mind as, you guessed it, ‘fascinating.’ I still use it, though again without overusing it. My godmother wished heartily that I hadn’t begun using it either, because in fairly short order many in our class were answering questions with ‘indeed’ and offering the observation, ‘fascinating,’ for just about everything. But I still do use it, and in any language I pick up, whether German, Russian, Spanish, or anything else, I make quite sure to know those two terms in that language. Why? Just in case.
Finally, we come to logic. By ‘logic,’ I only mean the word ‘logic’ and its various inflected forms ‘logical,’ ‘logically,’ etc. ‘Logic’ is another word that doesn’t get used terribly often outside specialized speaking or writing. If we’re talking about rhetoric, or discussing some philosophical issue or picking apart my dissertation’s study design and protocols, the word ‘logic’ may occur alarmingly often. In everyday chitchat, however, it’s not used as much. Yet, I use it. I refer to things as being logical or being illogical’ or ‘not logical.’ I occasionally begin a thoughtful statement with phrases such as: “logic suggests,” “logic dictates,” “it would be logical to assume that,” etc. I freely admit that in the beginning, i.e. when I was a preteen, my use of these phrases was conscious and for effect. That is to say I used them because they sounded impressive and intelligent. And they were intelligent. But would I have done so without encountering Spock? Indeed not. Nowadays the word is such an ingrained part of my personal lexicon that my use of it is generally unconscious and usually without any conscious reference to Spock. In one telling argument I had about a year ago, I can tell you that I, fighting back deep disappointment and anger, said in what I am told was a calm and controlled tone with no hint of strong emotion to it, “your logic, is flawed.” I don’t remember whether I did say it, but the person in question has never forgotten it, and she reminded me of it some months later when we, fully passed our disagreement, were discussing Spock as a character. It was her observation that Spock had worked his way into my core, and this was an example she chose to bring up. I found her supposition most … well … logical, and as such, it leads me into my next segment.
“My thoughts, to your thoughts,” my thinking and Spock
Ask any reputable psychologist and they’ll tell you that your core personality traits and modes of self-expression are fairly well set by the time you’re five years old or thereabouts. Everything after that is, I would surmise, icing on the cake or conscious control of your modes of self-expression. So no, no psychologist would accept at face value the claim that Spock had a fundamental impact on my personality makeup. I won’t split that hair with you, because I’m not a psychologist, though I flatter myself in thinking I know myself and my own mind quite well. So, I would say that Spock became embedded in my patterns of thought and gave voice to my more analytical tendencies. There’s my nod to psychology, now for what really happened.
I was attracted to the Vulcan way of thought as a child. Note: I’m very, very comfortable with emotions; just ask my fiance. Nevertheless, to think logically all the time was, to a twelve-year-old, quite novel and quite attractive. How nice it would be to respond to middle school bullies with an icy stare and a raised eyebrow. On my good days, that is, days when I did not retaliate against schoolyard bullies who were picking on me (the blind kid) with violence of my own, I would often take pleasure in perplexing my tormentors with such rejoinders as, “I fail to comprehend the logic of your actions,” or, “where is the logic in this,” or, “I find your chosen behavior most curious.” This usually stopped the ragging, not because of my brilliance, but because what I said was a bit difficult for my peers to process. I often slipped away while they traded puzzled stares.
It also helped my fascination with Spock that I, thanks to a voracious appetite for books, had acquired and been using a very broad and deep vocabulary. My peers began yelling at me around age 11 because no one understood what I was saying. As a linguist, I can say now that my problem was simply that I had no concept of appropriate register. Fascinating. In any case, Spock talked the way I did, or the way people told the young Brad that he talked. So imitating his speech patterns was exceptionally easy and became unconscious in fairly short order. I’m told, even today, that when I am in the depths of scholarly analysis or logical inference, my speech takes on the rhythms and stress patterns of Spock, or more likely, of typical Vulcan stress and intonation. Though having said that, I would hope my speech more closely resembles the meticulous and considered tones of Spock, and not the clipped bruskness of Tuvok’s speech. Only my friends could tell me that. But on with the anecdotes.
I was attracted to Spock’s way of logical behavior, because logic gave him a way to control his emotions. Not to say that Vulcans don’t have them or even that they claim not to have emotions. Neither is true. But the Vulcan ethic of controlled emotion, of emotion that did not pick you up and carry you away in its thrall was wildly appealing on bad days. How nice it would be, for example, not to cry or shout or to feel hurt or disappointment. Not, as I knew, that Vulcans would not have felt the disappointment, but you’d never have known that they did. Not unless you were looking, because Vulcans, i.e. Spock, held his emotions in subjection to his intellect and chose, through discipline of will, not to be dominated by them. This is, for the average human teen, in a word, impossible.
Take my first teenage breakup. I was fourteen, and I was devastated. Weren’t we all? I remember it clearly. I remember collapsing outside the high school gym in tears, cursing myself bitterly. Why cursing myself? Because I was crying and that was a sign of weakness in a boy? No. I was cursing myself because I had, having had some foreknowledge of the breakup, resolved not to allow tears. I would, I told myself most sternly even as I lost it, handle the situation logically. I would accept that what had happened was done and that, logically, I must continue from that point onwards. Very true. Very logical advice, and impossible to follow it. I remember thinking to myself, “see there, you are no Vulcan.”
Or another example. My parents’ divorce was hard. Show me one that isn’t? I attempted to understand the reasons logically. Cause and effect. If they were divorcing, then logically, there was a first cause of the divorce, so my fifteen-year-old brain reasoned. If I could find the divorce’s primary cause, I could untangle the train of events that lead to it and thereby understand, that is, place into a logical framework of cause and consequence, all the events that befell my family between 1997 and 1999. Well as you can guess, I’m not about to explain my parents’ divorce. Let me say that in this effort I eventually succeeded. It took many years. I suffered from what Spock would call “insufficient data,” but I can now, with reason that is sound, give a logical account of my parents’ marriage and its ending. Not that all marriages have logical endings, but when all data are present, the logic of the situation becomes clear at once. That is not to say that it is a comfort. Logic, in this case, merely provided answers.
Two more telling items. As my fiancé will attest, Spock affects my ways of arguing. Spock, and my parents. Put it this way. My parents screamed and shouted. I do not. I find shouting and insults counterproductive, and to use them is to work at cross-purposes at resolving the conflict. Sounds like something Spock would say about human arguments, doesn’t it? And it’s true. When I’m angry, I speak softly, even coldly, explaining the offense that was given and seeking solutions. This works best with disagreements, where the two parties can discuss the offense, real or perceived, and arrive at an understanding and a resolution. So, as many will tell you, I argue calmly and logically. The phrase, “your logic, is flawed,” quoted above, was something I said not to impress my opponent or to crush her arguments, but because her angry arguments were, without going into detail, based on flawed premises and insufficient data. That’s not to say that I wasn’t emotionally involved in the argument. Indeed, quite the contrary. But in the midst of that painful disagreement, I felt it my duty to reach her not through emotional appeals for sympathy or by shouting at her, but by telling her quite calmly that she was mistaken and that, well, her logic was in error. And so it was. If only all human conflicts could be settled by recourse to reason. Thankfully, that one was.
Now we come to faith. Faith is an interesting topic on a whole variety of levels, and here Spock’s influence was less direct. I struggled, however, to reconcile the desire to reason with the need for faith and belief. This paragraph deserves its own book, but that is not my purpose. Suffice it to say that I was uncertain where or whether reason and faith co-existed intellectually. And then I was reminded of Spock’s comments about faith in Star Trek VI. These comments are the only occasion I can think of when a Vulcan refers to a need for faith. See the quotations section below. Long, long, story short, I came to understand that logic is only a portion of wisdom, and that faith is necessary for a balanced perspective. What is more, Spock said so himself. Again, see below.
Meeting the Man
I will never forget late July of 2004. It was my only star trek convention, and I was going to make it count. Leonard wasn’t the first star trek actor I met and shook hands with. That was George Takay, who I greeted in Japanese. But I will not forget meeting Leonard just the same. Standing in the long line, feeling the same nervous anticipation as all the rest of the fans. The difference was this. I wasn’t straining to see his face or catch a glimpse of him. I have no vision, so to expect me to have done so would not be logical. But rather I was straining my hearing, awaiting his voice, a voice I knew well. I know it as well as I know those of my closest friends, and were the man to greet me on the street, I would recognize him instantly, so familiar are his speech patterns and inflections. You see, aside from his acting, Leonard has voiced a number of books and TV shows, and his intonations and verbal inflections are, to my trained ear, most distinctive and unforgettable. And finally the moment arrived.
I had, for all my preparation and anticipation, not managed to come up with anything inspired or anything that he would remember. But shaking his hand is a moment I will not forget. It was a steady hand, not palsied with age and not trembling in the slightest, though it was unquestionably the hand of an older man. Obviously, since he was 73 when we met. I sat down for the photo for which I’d paid, and it was duly taken. I should also mention that Leonard enjoyed my service dog at the time, a black lab named Rudy and the only dog at the con so far as I know. He’s retired now, Rudy, not Leonard. But when Leonard Nimoy asks for permission to pet your on-duty service animal, you say yes unhesitatingly, in case anyone wanted to know the proper response to that request under those conditions. Later that day, I also paid a bit extra to be able to stay behind during the autograph session, ostensibly to get something autographed after his talk. I had nothing to autograph. I did, however, have just a moment to say something to him. That is, I had a bit more time. I chose with my thirty seconds, to thank him for something that he probably doesn’t get thanked for very often, his book narration. Narration, especially of a dramatized book like your average star trek novel, is a time consuming and generally unsung task. Unsung, because most fans will pick up the unabridged version in paperback and read it without giving it a thought. I had the novel Vulcan’s Forge in mind, which focuses on Spock as the primary protagonist. Nimoy narrated it and he did so very well. It’s probably among the least known of his narrative tasks. The Alien Voices project and Spock Versus Q are better known, because they were always meant to be something done as an audio recording. This novel appeared in print first, and only because he chose to narrate it did it ever appear in a form I could appreciate. It’s not my favorite star trek novel, nor does it stand out among the best of the best, but narration is a task that more people should be thanked for, and that was one of my opportunities to do so. Incidentally, Leonard also narrates abridged versions of I am Spock, his second autobiography, Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, Star Trek V: The Final Frontier, Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, and he has supporting narrative roles in Star Trek: The Entropy Effect as well as in the abridged and dramatized versions of Enterprise, The first Adventure. Again, the man’s good. I hope that one day, when graduate school is over as it soon will be, I may return to a star trek convention and meet him one more time. I will never have the opportunity to sit down and have an actual conversation with him, much to my regret. And whereas many people fantasize about this or that or meeting so and so under thus and such conditions, I wish merely to have a conversation. And it shall likely never come to pass. That is, there is no logical reason to suppose that it should do so. Indeed.
Quotations
Below I have listed some of my favorite quotes. In many cases, I’ve provided some of the immediately surrounding dialogue as context, and in every case I’ve cited the episode or movie from which the lines were taken. Such is, sadly, my training as a scholar, to cite. I haven’t made any great effort to put them in chronological order, but the episodes are listed before the movies, and the movies appear in order. That’s orderly enough. Enjoy the quotes. I always have.
The Original Episodes, 20 quotes
Lt. Bailey: “It’s blocking the way!”
Spock: “Quite unnecessary to raise your voice, Mr. Bailey.”
Lt. Bailey: “Raising my voice back there doesn’t mean I was scared or couldn’t do my job. It means I happen to have a human thing called an adrenalin gland.”
Spock: “That sounds most inconvenient, however. Have you considered having it removed?”
TOS: The Corbomite Maneuver.
Spock: “Save her, do as your heart tells you to do, and millions will die who did not die before.”
TOS: The City on the Edge of Forever.
Spock: “Captain, must we?”
Kirk: “It’s faster than walking.”
Spock: “Yes, but not as safe.”
Kirk: “Are you afraid of cars, Mr. Spock?”
Spock: “Not at all, Captain. It’s your driving that alarms me.”
TOS: A Piece of the Action.
Spock: “Logic and practical information do not seem to apply here.”
McCoy: “You admit that?”
Spock: “To deny the facts would be illogical, Doctor.”
TOS: A Piece of the Action.
Spock: [using a Chicago gangster accent] “I would advise yas to keep dialin’, Oxmyx.”
TOS: A Piece of the Action.
Kirk: “A child suppresses the fact that both parents are dead? I can’t believe it.”
Spock: “Humans do have an amazing capacity for believing what they choose and excluding that which is painful.”
TOS: And the Children Shall Lead.
Kirk: “Well there it is, war. We didn’t want it, but we’ve got it.”
Spock: “Curious how often you humans manage to obtain that which you do not want.”
TOS: Errand of Mercy.
Spock: “You may find that having is not so nearly pleasing a thing is wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true.”
TOS: Amuck Time.
McCoy: “Did it ever occur to you that he simply might like the girl?”
Spock: “It occurred. I dismissed it.”
McCoy: “You would.”
TOS: The Conscience of the King.
Spock: “Ladies and Gentlemen, please move away from the chamber or you may be injured.”
Ambassador Fox: “What are you doing, Mr. Spock?”
Spock: “Practicing a peculiar variety of diplomacy, Sir.”
TOS: A Taste of Armageddon.
Spock: “Gentlemen, There is one thing which requires the immediate attention of all of us. Specifically, our future.”
TOS: Specter of the Gun.
Mudd: “’’’ And do you know what the penalty for fraud is on Deneb Five?”
Spock: “The guilty party has his choice. Death by electrocution, death by gas, death by phaser, death by hanging,”
Mudd: “The key word in your entire peroration Mr. Spock is, death.”
TOS: I, Mudd.
Spock: [to an android] “Logic is a little tweeting bird chirping in a meadow. Logic is a wreath of flowers which smell bad. Are you sure your circuits are functioning correctly? Your ears are green.”
TOS: I, Mudd.
Spock: “… In a manner of speaking, Captain, we have given the people of Vol the apple, the knowledge of good and evil if you will, as a result of which they too have been driven out of paradise.”
TOS: The Apple.
Spock: “I have a responsibility to this ship. To that man on the bridge. I am what I am, Leila, and if there are self made purgatories, then we all have to live in them. Mine can be no worse than someone else’s.”
TOS: This Side of Paradise.
Spock: “I’ve never understood the female capacity to avoid a direct answer to any question.”
TOS: This Side of Paradise.
Kirk: “Was that a threat?”
[mirror] Spock: “I do not threaten, Captain. I merely state facts.”
TOS: Mirror, Mirror.
[mirror] Spock: “Terror must be maintained or the empire is doomed. It is the logic of history.”
TOS: Mirror, Mirror.
Spock: “Those who hate and fight must stop themselves, Doctor. Otherwise it is not stopped.”
TOS: Day of the Dove.
Spock: “All that matters to them … is their hate.”
Uhura: “Do you suppose that’s all they ever had, Sir?”
Kirk: “No, but that’s all they have left.”
TOS: Let That Be Your Last Battlefield.
Movie Quotes
McCoy: “Spock, this child is about to wipe out every living thing on Earth. Now what do you suggest we do, spank it?”
Spock: “It knows only that it needs, Commander … But, like so many of us ... it does not know what.”
Star Trek I: The Motion Picture.
Spock: “If I may be so bold, it was a mistake for you to accept promotion. Commanding a starship is your first, best destiny. Anything else is a waste of material.”
Kirk: “I would not presume to debate you.”
Spock: “That is wise. Were I to invoke logic, however, logic clearly dictates that the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.”
Kirk: “Or the one.”
Spock: “You are my superior officer. You are also my friend. I have been and always shall be yours.”
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan
Spock: “Jim, you proceed from a false assumption. I am a Vulcan. I have no ego to bruise.”
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan.
Spock: “The ship … out of danger?”
Kirk: “Yes.”
Spock: “Do not grieve, Admiral. The needs of the many, outweigh …”
Kirk: “The needs of the few.”
Spock: “Or the one. I never took the Kobayashi Maru test until now. What do you think of my solution? … I have been and always shall be your friend. … Live long, and prosper.”
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan.
Spock: “Jim, your name … is Jim.”
Star Trek III: The Search for Spock.
Spock: “Excuse me, Admiral, but weren’t those a birthday gift from Doctor McCoy?”
Kirk: “And they will be again. That’s the beauty of it.”
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
Spock: “What does it mean, ‘exact change?’”
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
Kirk: “If we play our cards right, we may be able to find out when those whales are being released.”
Spock: “How will playing cards help?”
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
Gillian: “Do you guys like Italian?”
Kirk: “Yes.”
Spock: “No.”
Kirk: “Yes.”
Spock: “No.”
Kirk: “Yes. I love Italian, and so do you.”
Spock: “Yes.”
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
Gillian: “Sure you won’t change your mind?”
Spock: “Is there something wrong with the one I have?”
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
Kirk: “Where the hell’s the power you promised?”
Spock: “One damned minute Admiral.”
Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home.
Spock: “I do not believe you realize the gravity of your situation.”
Kirk: “On the contrary, gravity is foremost on my mind.”
Star Trek V: The Final Frontier.
Spock: “Perhaps ‘because it is there’ is not sufficient reason for climbing a mountain.”
Kirk: “I am hardly in a position to disagree.”
Star Trek V: The Final Frontier.
Kirk: “I thought I was going to die.”
Spock: “Not possible. You were never alone.”
Star Trek V: The Final Frontier.
Valaris: “Sir, I address you as a kindred intellect. Do you not realize that a turning point has been reached in the affairs of the Federation?”
Spock: “History is replete with turning points, Lieutenant. You must have faith.”
Valaris: “Faith?”
Spock: “That the universe will unfold as it should.”
Valaris: “But is that logical? Surely we must—“
Spock: “Logic, logic, logic. Logic is the beginning of wisdom, Lieutenant, not the end.”
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country.
Spock: “We must endeavor to piece together what happened here tonight. According to our data banks, this ship fired those torpedoes. If we did, the killers are here. If we did not, whoever altered the data banks is here. In either case, what we are searching for is here.”
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country.
Spock: “You have to shoot. If you are logical, you have to shoot.”
Valaris: “I do not want to.”
Spock: “What you want is irrelevant, what you have chosen is at hand.”
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country.
Spock: “Doctor, would you care to assist me in performing surgery on a torpedo?”
McCoy: “Fascinating.”
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country.
Spock: “Is it possible that we two, you and I, have grown so old and so inflexible as to have outlived our usefulness? Would that constitute a joke?”
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country.
Uhura: “We’re to return to space dock. To be decommissioned.”
Spock: “If I were human, I believe my response would be … go to hell. If, I were human.”
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country.
Spock: “In your own way, you are as stubborn as another captain of the Enterprise I once knew.”
TNG: Unification, Part II.
Spock: “It is possible that I have brought my argument with Sarek to you, Captain. If so I apologize.”
Picard: “Is it so important that you win one last argument with him?”
Spock: “No it is not. But it is true I will miss the arguments. They were, finally, all that we had.”
TNG: Unification, Part II.
Pardek: “How could they know of this location? Someone has betrayed us!”
Spock: “Yes, you did.”
Pardek: “Spock! We’ve been friends for eighty years!”
Spock: “It is the only logical conclusion. You asked me to come to Romulus, you arranged the meetings with the Proconsul, and you knew that Picard and Data had returned to the surface with new information.”
TNG: Unification, part II.
Spock: “I will not read this or any other statement.”
Sela: “If you do not, you will die. All of you will die.”
Spock: “Since it is logical to conclude that you will kill us in any event, I choose not to cooperate.”
TNG, Unification Part II.
